Evaluate Weigh the pros and cons of technologies, products and projects you are considering.

Clearing up the WebSphere tools confusion

Find out which WebSphere tools are right for you.

There's WebSphere Studio, WebSphere Development Studio Client (WDSC) and WebSphere Studio Application Developer (WSAD) 4.0. Now there's WSAD 5.0.

Right about now, you're probably scratching your head and wondering, "OK. Which one do I go with?" Let's see if we can help you out.

If you purchased Visual Age for Java Enterprise Edition and WebSphere Studio 3.5 and have a Passport Advantage Subscription, you were entitled to upgrade to WSAD 4.0 in January. WSAD 4.0 was IBM's first release of the new integrated Eclipse-based Java and Web development tools for the Enterprise. WSAD 4.0 has been out for less than six months, and now we have WSAD 5.0 using IBM's new-and-improved Eclipse 2.0.

Confusion about the various WebSphere tools has come about because iSeries users also have the WDSC tools. If you're running the WebSphere Application Server (Advanced Edition or Single Server) and you want to develop enterprise Java beans, you must purchase WSAD. WDSC has many iSeries-specific tools, support for legacy application development like RPG and COBOL via CODE/400 and the incredible new WebFacing tool, but it doesn't do enterprise Java beans.

If you install WSAD 4.0, you may then install the WDSC on top of it. And because both are based on Eclipse 1.0, the WDSC will install only those iSeries-specific tools that do not exist in the WSAD, giving you the best of both worlds.

WDSC is NOT yet compatible with WSAD 5.0. So, why would you care about 5.0? WSAD 5.0 is a major upgrade in Java technology and standards support. WSAD 5.0 now supports J2EE 1.3, including EJB 2.0, Servlet 2.3 and JSP 1.2.

WSAD 5.0 also includes support for WebSphere Application Server 5.0 as well as support for version 4.0. You choose your environment when you test or deploy. A complete test environment exists for both version 4 and version 5. You may also use the built-in test server or point to a remote server for your testing and debugging.

In terms of features, the focus of WSAD 5.0 has been on technology. For you VisualAge for Java JSP developers who realized that WSAD 4.0 did not include a JSP debugger, you will be extremely pleased with the support in WSAD 5.0. It now includes an extremely robust JSP debugger.

Many of you have become extremely comfortable with VisualAge for Java and have an "I'd rather fight than switch" attitude. I strongly suggest you get over it, especially if you are using Java to build Web applications.

To be kind, WebSphere Studio 3.5, which shipped with VisualAge for Java Enterprise 4.0, was at best primitive. The new tools seamlessly integrate Web development, testing and deployment with a Java development environment that is more robust than VisualAge.

If you have a passport advantage software subscription, download WSAD 5.0 from IBM's Passport Advantage Web site and give it a spin. You will not go back to VisualAge. Just a footnote, the folks who poured all of the loving development into VisualAge for Java are the same folks building WSAD. They will not disappoint you.

For more information about the product, go to http://www-3.ibm.com/software/ad/studioappdev/about/V5.html.

About the author: Bob Cancilla is managing director of IGNITe/400, an electronic iSeries 400 Internet users group. He is also author of the book Getting Down to e-business with AS/400 and IBM eServer iSeries: Built for e-business.


  • Get started building Java Web apps in WDSC
    IBM's WebSphere Development Studio Client (WDSC) for iSeries is a powerful, easy-to-use tool for building every type of Web application you can think of. This guided tutorial shows how to build some simple Java Web applications quickly that access iSeries data and call RPG programs with a browser interface.
  • iSeries WebSphere strategy update: Improvements on the way
    Site expert Jim Mason reviews IBM's new WebSphere strategy for version 5, which fixes many of the problems the version 4 strategy created. WebSphere IS becoming more widely used in iSeries shops, and this upgrade should make that happen faster, especially for midsize companies.
  • Basic WebSphere troubleshooting concepts
    If you're new to WebSphere, you're sure to come upon some problems that you need help figuring out. This tip introduces WebSphere basic concepts and a simple process to help identify some WebSphere configuration problems quickly.
  • .26RlaSVDeTg^1@.ee84637>WebSphere/Web development discussion forum:
    Post your WebSphere and Web development questions here. You'll get advice from our site experts who monitor the forum, as well as ideas and suggestions from other users.
  • Best Web Links on Web Development

Dig Deeper on Web Tools

Start the conversation

Send me notifications when other members comment.

Please create a username to comment.